The developed ontologies are evaluated regarding the FAIRsFAIR Recommendations for Ontology Publication based on the analysis presented by Poveda-Villalón et al (2020):
Poveda-Villalón, M., Espinoza-Arias, P., Garijo, D., Corcho, O. (2020). Coming to Terms with FAIR Ontologies. In: Keet, C.M., Dumontier, M. (eds) Knowledge Engineering and Knowledge Management. EKAW 2020. Lecture Notes in Computer Science(), vol 12387. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-61244-3_18
and the original publication in:
Le Franc, Y., Parland-von Essen, J., Bonino, L., Lehvaslaiho, H., Coen, G., Staiger,
C.: D2.2 FAIR semantics: first recommendations, March 2020. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.3707985
| Req. | Description | LOIN | DT | ISOProps |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| P-Rec1: | Use Globally Unique, Persistent and Resolvable Identifier for Semantic Artefacts, their content and their versions. | http://w3id.org/loin | http://w3id.org/dt | http://w3id.org/isoprops |
| P-Rec2: | Use Globally Unique, Persistent and Resolvable Identifier for Semantic Artefact Metadata Record. | http://w3id.org/loin | http://w3id.org/dt | http://w3id.org/isoprops |
| P-Rec3: | Use a common minimum metadata schema to describe semantic artefacts and their content. | dc terms, schema.org, vann | dc terms, schema.org, vann | dc terms, schema.org, vann, skos |
| P-Rec4: | Publish the Semantic Artefact and its content in a semantic repository. | https://prefix.cc/loin registered https://lov.linkeddata.es (LOV) registration ongoing |
https://lov.linkeddata.es (LOV) registration ongoing, https://prefix.cc/dt ongoing | https://prefix.cc/isoprops registered https://lov.linkeddata.es (LOV) registration ongoing |
| P-Rec5: | Semantic repositories should offer a common API to access semantic artefacts and their content in various serializations for both use/reuse and indexation by any search engines. | LOV registration ongoing | LOV registration ongoing | LOV registration ongoing |
| P-Rec6: | Build semantic artefacts’ search engines that operate across different semantic repositories. | LOV registration ongoing | LOV registration ongoing | LOV registration ongoing |
| P-Rec7: | Repositories should offer a secure protocol and user access control functionalities. | LOV registration ongoing | LOV registration ongoing | LOV registration ongoing |
| P-Rec8: | Define human and machine-readable persistency policies for semantic artefacts metadata. | LOV registration ongoing | LOV registration ongoing | LOV registration ongoing |
| P-Rec9: | Semantic artefacts should be represented using common serialization formats, e.g., Semantic Web and Linked Data standards. | RDF/XML,TTL,JSON-LD,N-Triples | RDF/XML,TTL,JSON-LD,N-Triples | RDF/XML,TTL,JSON-LD,N-Triples |
| P-Rec10: | Use a Foundational Ontology to align semantic artefacts. | not applied | not applied | not applied |
| P-Rec11: | Use a standardized language for describing semantic artefacts. | RDF / RDFS / OWL | RDF / RDFS / OWL | RDF / RDFS / OWL |
| P-Rec12: | Semantic mappings between the different elements of semantic artefacts should use machine-readable formats based on W3C standards. | aligned with DT and ISOProps ontology | aligned with LOIN and ISOProps ontology | aligned with DT and LOIN ontology |
| P-Rec13: | Crosswalks, mappings and bridging between semantic artefacts should be documented, published and curated. | documented | documented | documented |
| P-Rec14: | Use standard vocabularies to describe semantic artefacts. | dc terms, schema.org, vann | dc terms, schema.org, vann | dc terms, schema.org, vann, skos |
| P-Rec15: | Make the references to the reused third-party semantic artefacts explicit. | imports documented | imports documented | imports documented |
| P-Rec16: | The semantic artefact should be clearly licensed for machines and humans. | CC-BY-40 | CC-BY-40 | CC-BY-40 |
| P-Rec17: | Provenance should be clear for both humans and machines. | documented in paper: ISO7817 | documented in paper: ISO23387 | documented in paper: ISO23386 |